Citrine vs. Orange Calcite: Here’s the Difference

When you look at orange calcite and citrine, it’s easy to mix them up because they both shine in beautiful shades of yellow and orange. However, these two gemstones are distinct in their properties and characteristics.

If you own one of these crystals but are puzzled about their differences, let’s delve into what sets them apart.

What are the differences between citrine and orange calcite?

Visually

A way to tell the difference is by their appearance.

If you’ve got a real, natural citrine on hand, it’s usually found in clusters or pointed shapes, quite similar to clear quartz. Orange calcite, on the other hand, tends to be a vibrant orange with white streaks. When it comes to ctrine that’s actually heat-treated amethyst, the tip-off is usually the coloration: the top is often dark orange while the bottom is white.

Calcite can range from opaque to somewhat see-through, while citrine has a more translucent, almost glowing look when it’s cut and polished.  While both stones come in shades of yellow and orange, they hail from different parts of the world. Orange calcite is more commonly found and comes from places like Mexico, Canada, and the USA. Citrine, however, is rarer and is sourced from countries like Russia and Madagascar.

Calcite and citrine might look similar at a glance, especially when it comes to their yellow color, which comes from iron impurities. However, when you look closer, you’ll notice differences.

 

The two gems also belong to different mineral classes.

The hardness test

Firstly, one of the most straightforward ways to distinguish them is by testing their hardness. This is a simple scratch test that you can do right at home. Grab your specimen and find a clean, unscratched surface on it. Hold it steady and try scratching it with a knife blade, a fingernail, a steel file, or even a quartz crystal—each with its own known hardness level. If your specimen scratches easily, you’re holding orange calcite. If not, you’re in the presence of citrine.  Be mindful, though, as this can do damage.

Orange calcite is a carbonate mineral, whereas citrine is a silicate. When it comes to hardness, Citrine scores a 7 on the Mohs scale, making it considerably harder than orange calcite, which sits at a 3. That means you’ll need to be more cautious with orange calcite, as it’s softer and could fade when exposed to light or water for too long.

If you’re trying to tell the difference between calcite and citrine, there are a few clues to look for.

Orange calcite, for example, usually has streaks of white, while citrine is consistently yellow throughout. Also, calcite might appear a bit cloudy or dense, while citrine has a more transparent, polished look. When it comes to shine, polished calcites are generally less shiny than citrines. If you see a yellow stone with a high gloss, it’s likely citrine.

In terms of honey calcite versus citrine, the calcite is generally more vivid, with striking orange tops that make it look like a heat-treated amethyst.

Comparing citrine and orange calcite

Colors:  When you’re comparing calcite and citrine, a few things jump out right away. Both of these stones come in shades of yellow, but there are some subtle differences. Calcite is more of a transparent yellow, while citrine ranges from translucent to a more opaque yellow.

Chakra differences:  Both of these stones are connected to the solar plexus chakra, which is related to self-confidence and personal power. But citrine takes it a step further by also interacting with other lower chakras. Both stones are beneficial for physical healing, boosting courage, and lifting confidence, but they’re best used individually for specific tasks like cleansing and charging energy.

Durability:  As far as durability is concerned, citrine ranks higher on the Mohs scale at 6, making it more resistant to scratches and wear than calcite, which ranks at 3.

Elements and planets:  Now, let’s talk about the elements and planets that are said to rule these stones. Calcite is governed by the element of water and is associated with Venus and the Moon. Citrine, on the other hand, is connected to the element of air and has the Sun and Jupiter as its ruling planets.

Metaphysical:  When it comes to healing, both stones have their merits, but they function differently. Calcite is known for its ability to cleanse negativity, especially on the physical level. Citrine, however, takes a more comprehensive approach. It not only amplifies physical healing and health but also works on a spiritual level by clearing any blocks or challenges you might have. It’s even said to attract good luck and fortune your way.

Summary

Citrine

1. Hardness: Citrine is pretty tough; it scores a 7 out of 10 on the Mohs hardness scale. That means it’s not easy to scratch.
2. Color: It ranges from yellow to deep orange, and sometimes you’ll even see a brownish tint.
3. Transparency: Citrine is usually transparent, which means you can see through it like glass.
4. Luster: It has a shiny, glass-like surface that catches the light well.
5. Streak: If you were to rub citrine on a white tile, it would leave a white streak.
6. Formation: It’s formed when amethyst, another type of quartz, is heated either naturally or artificially.
7. Durability: Because it’s hard, citrine is great for everyday jewelry like rings and necklaces.
8. Origin: You’ll often find citrine in places like Brazil, Madagascar, and Russia.

Orange Calcite

1. Hardness: Orange calcite is softer, with a Mohs hardness of just 3. It can get scratched more easily.
2. Color: Its color is usually a bright, pure orange, sometimes with white or clear areas.
3. Transparency: This stone can range from transparent to translucent, meaning light can pass through it, but you might not see clearly through the stone.
4. Luster: It has a more waxy or resin-like shine, not as glassy as citrine.
5. Streak: Like citrine, orange calcite also leaves a white streak when rubbed on a tile.
6. Formation: It forms from mineral-rich water and is often found in limestone and marble.
7. Durability: Because it’s softer, it’s not the best choice for jewelry that you’ll wear all the time.
8. Origin: You can commonly find orange calcite in Mexico.

Exploring calcite

Calcite is a versatile crystal that comes in a variety of colors like white, red, , brown, green, in addition to yellow. This crystal is known for its strong vibrations and its potential to rid people of ailments, fears, and negative thoughts.

It is mainly composed of calcium carbonate and is one of the most common minerals you’ll find. Its vibrant orange hues result from the way light interacts with tiny iron oxide particles inside the stone. While it occurs worldwide, it’s notably found in sedimentary, metamorphic, and igneous rocks in countries like Mexico, Canada, and the USA. The stone also comes in other colors, influenced by various impurities. Each color corresponds to a different major chakra.

Yellow calcite and orange calcite, for example, are two varieties that look a lot like citrine. Yellow calcite is closely linked to the solar plexus chakra, whereas orange calcite is associated with the root, solar plexus and third eye chakras. Calcite stones also have a balancing and cleansing effect on people and spaces by removing negativity. They can also help to soothe anger and bring calmness.

➡️ Looking for CITRINE OR ORANGE CALCITE? Check out my Etsy or Shop

Yellow calcite’s impact on body, spirit, and mind

If you’re wondering how yellow calcite can affect you, let’s dig into its metaphysical attributes.

If you’re in need of a pick-me-up, orange calcite could be the stone for you. It’s strongly linked to the Sacral and Solar Plexus chakras, making it great for boosting self-confidence and emotional well-being. This sunny crystal can help you overcome fears, insecurities, and even depressive states.

When worn or carried, orange calcite helps clear blockages that might be keeping you from your true potential. It’s particularly motivating and can inspire you when you need that extra push to achieve your goals. If you’re struggling with sexual drive, this crystal can provide healing and understanding, enhancing your body’s natural pleasures.

Orange calcite also promotes creativity. It stimulates your imagination and helps you solve problems more swiftly. Physically, it’s good for restoring balance in your body and is known to strengthen the spleen, liver, and kidneys. It’s also useful for treating issues related to the reproductive system and can help flush toxins from your body.

Regarding your mental well-being, yellow calcite is like a breath of fresh air. It’s the go-to stone for sweeping away mental fog and confusion. It’s also said to help with eliminating negative thoughts and shielding your aura from harmful energies.

Understanding citrine

Citrine is a type of quartz that has won over hearts as the second most popular gem in its family. While it’s a go-to choice for jewelry, its uses extend to home decor and even crystal healing. The name “Citrine” has its roots in the French word “citron,” which means lemon—aptly describing its sunny color. This gem is said to embody the full vitality of the sun itself.

Color-wise, citrine varies from a gentle yellow to a deep, dark orange. It’s a pretty tough stone, scoring a 7 on the Mohs hardness scale, although it can lose its vibrant color if left in direct sunlight for too long. Unlike some other crystals, citrine can be safely placed in water. Natural Citrine is rare and mainly found in places like the Ural Mountains in Russia and Madagascar. Most of what you see in stores is actually heat-treated Amethyst.

Citrine is often called a good luck charm. Many people believe it brings wealth, especially when stored in places like wallets, for instance. While it may resemble yellow calcite in appearance, citrine is much more versatile, particularly when it comes to affecting multiple chakras, the energy centers in your body.

You can use citrine not only as a lucky charm but also to energize and use grids designed to bring good fortune. This makes it a pretty useful crystal to have around.

Citrine metaphysical properties

If you’re looking to add a dose of happiness or abundance to your life, citrine might be the stone for you. Often dubbed the “Merchant’s Stone,” it has a reputation for drawing wealth and success, making it a great companion for your business endeavors. Just keeping it in your pocket or purse can up your financial luck and create a more positive energy flow.

But citrine’s benefits go beyond material wealth.

The stone’s sunny hue captures the essence of joy, happiness, and the warm months of summer. It’s an energy booster that can rid a space of negative vibes and replace them with uplifting energy. This gem is tied to the solar plexus chakra, which means it can help generate a more vibrant and positive energy flow through your body.

On the spiritual side, citrine is like an all-in-one package. It not only affects multiple chakras but also wakes up your kundalini, your inner life force. This brings a host of benefits like  luck and prosperity. And that’s not all; citrine is like a positivity powerhouse. It adds balance and success to your spiritual life. To fully tap into its power, you can charge it with different methods like incense or singing bowls.

If you’re feeling down, citrine may serve as an emotional pick-me-up. While calcite is known for clearing your mind, citrine fills it with positive thoughts. It’s a real mood enhancer. Charging it in the sunlight for a few minutes can help bring emotional balance into your life.

Which one is better?

At first glance, orange calcite and citrine might look like twins, but anyone passionate about crystals knows that these two have unique qualities. Despite their color similarities, which make them good for energizing the same chakras—the Sacral and Solar Plexus—they each bring something distinct to the table.

Both crystals are excellent mood boosters. If you’re looking to shake off negative thoughts, fight off gloom, or simply carry a pocketful of happiness, either of these could be your go-to. They also play well together, so you can carry both if you like, and double up on those good vibes.

However, there are some key differences to keep in mind. If you’re interested in wealth and prosperity, citrine has that territory well covered.

On the flip side, if you’re budget-conscious, orange calcite might be more your speed; it’s generally more affordable, given its common occurrence compared to the rarity and high price of natural Citrine. Be cautious when you find a ‘bargain’ citrine—it’s likely heat-treated Amethyst.

Durability is another area where these two diverge.

Orange calcite is on the softer side, which means you should think twice about wearing it as jewelry or tossing it casually into your pocket. It’s susceptible to scratches, breaks, and dents. Citrine, being harder, is more robust and versatile. For instance, you can make gem elixirs with citrine, but it’s not recommended to use orange calcite in that way.

In the end, there’s no definitive answer to which is ‘better’—it really comes down to your personal preferences and needs.

Your best bet is to visit a metaphysical shop and hold each crystal to see how they resonate with you. If that’s not possible, browsing online with our store is another good option. Just go with whatever feels most ‘right’ for you, and you won’t go wrong.